The Hall of Fire

I am going to be brave and also jump in the discussion, even though you are already up to chapter 9, considering LotR...fairly young in the big picture. Also I haven't read all the articles and letters and such to the point that I can quote them or find reference to them. But I enjoy reading them wh...

Prim!! Thank you for responding.

In staying with this threads tradition, I am VERY late to the party. I did read all 9 pages :bow: and that is sayin' something. To answer the question in the thread title. I am on the side of not preferring TTT to FotR and RotK. For many reasons. As others have already stated, FotR....well it was sp...

Welcome Elentári!! I hope you enjoy this lovey website. And, that I get to know you as well.

I am trying, V.

Welcome Youngie. Hope to see you post.

Let me add the greeting to Vanadarlin' too.

Happy to see you here and hey, don't be a stranger...

Unlike someone else... Me.

Welcome to all new folks..:D Stormy...great to see you again. NOW.....Voronwë....YOU are the reason I am here, is there a thread which speaks of your trip to Africa? I would love to hear what you saw, what you smelled, what you ate...I love your siggie. :D I would just imagine that you had the very ...

Have a great trip to Africa Oh Shiny One...come back safe and take piccies if you dare. ;) Thanks for the great count down Mr. Genetically Superior one. I was not surprised at the top three. All make perfect sense to me and your reasoning behind them all also is telling. How long did this take you? ...

What are you trying to do to me here...geesh. I am gutted waiting for the posts of the last seven already!!

*passes oxygen to Voronwë*

Voronwë - that is in case I don't post with you again before you leave on your magical trip. Have a great holiday....

Move along, nothing to see here except me stalking Frelga and Voronwë!!

Hey be careful what you say about Rwhen's.... :x ;) I have been lurking again and had to add at this point to the Master of Genetics, this information has been very helpful to me as I am researching the Fëanoreans at the moment. Thanks. And I always call you the "Shiny One"...oh shiny one!...

Absolutely NOT too much. I am unsatable...(is that a word?) "Can't get enough of that funky stuff!!". So, it will take me a bit to get through the three sources you have left me, and I WILL read them. I will comment in the appropriate places. Regards your resubmission. You have gone farthe...

VtF...if I may be bold enough to call you by that. I found your observations totally cohesive and well thought out. Consider me in line for your .... book? Would that be...Arda Reconstructed: The Creation of the Published Silmarillion???? Did some internet checking, just to let you know. Regards the...

Good question, but I recall Tolkien writing several times "as if the ring had a will of its own." Such as when it "falls" off Isildurs finger and lies on the bottom of that river until...."gasp" Sméagol finds it and hides for countless years..and then again...."oop...

I hope it is okay if I jump in here. I have read the whole thread and I have a different response as to what most drew me in, what kept the story going. But it is not a "who". It is THE ring itself. Which is sort of a living entity for my reading and take on the series. It is the reason fo...

Thank you to three loverly folks..:D :bow: I shall do my best to spread my wings and get out of a one note posting situation. I think it will do me good. :D Question to Athrabeth: This is not picking your words apart, but when I read your post, a thought came to me based on the previous posts. IF yo...

Well I did and I don't even post here that much...:P (that was a joke to lighten up the tone) ;) To add to discussion on The Hobbit...PJ/Ramey/Shaye... I have been following the thread over at TORC as well and wanted to see if you folks had anything else to offer over here. I think it would be great...

Hello again Crucifer. Well first, I spelled your name wrong like five times on this board, but got it right on the other board. So that is what I finally "got".

and the is just cuz. I like to give hugs.

No other special reason.

Oh Gosh, my bad totally...of course it is supposed to be Ginny, not Jenny. WHAT WAS I THINKING. I will use the excuse that I am at work, yeah, that's it. :D Elfshadow...actually I agreed with most of your summary at TORC, so great minds sorta thing going on... ;) I am not really all that much of a s...

Hi Prim, thanks for replying. Yeah, well I DON'T have any spoilers for the book. I hope no one does. I will just wait till my copy comes via UPS on Saturday. I guess I will be spending Saturday and Sunday devouring the last book. I did make the post to the thread you linked for me (thanks again :hug...