I thought I would start a new thread rather than try to continue this conversation in the "Echo Chamber" thread. As was discussed there, there is an ongoing controversy involving the Democratic governor of Virginia, Ralph Northam, involving a racist picture in his medical school yearbook, and his subsequent denial that it was actually him in the picture, but admission that he appeared in blackface on another occasion. I said in that thread that I thought he should resign, and I still think so.

Then it came out that there is an allegation against the African-American Lt. Gov of the state, Justin Fairfax, that he sexually assaulted a woman at the 2004 Democratic National Convention. Fairfax denies the allegation, saying that the encounter was consensual. The woman who made the accusation eventually went public with details. In a very bizarre twist, she has hired the same attorneys that represented Dr. Blasey Ford, and Fairfax has hired the same attorneys that represented now-Justice Kavanaugh. Obviously I don't know the truth of the matter, but the allegation seems quite credible to me, and I think that Fairfax should resign too.

If Northam and Fairfax did resign, the state's Attorney General, Mark Herring, would become Governor. Well, it turns out that Herring, who had joined the chorus calling for Northam's resignation, also appeared in blackface when he was younger. So by his own argument, he should resign as well.

If Northam, Fairfax and Herring all resigned, the Republican Speaker of the House, Kirk Cox, would become Governor. So far as I know, he has not been accused of any racist or misogynistic actions. I doubt that it will come to that, but that is what I think should happen.

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

"If at any point in your life, you have ever said or done something that a historically marginalized group would find offensive at some level, you should be fired or resign whatever your current job is."

It's good that we are now more insistent on calling out inappropriate things as inappropriate, but the level of puritanicalism being demanded from the left seems absurd and irrational to me.

_________________
I wanna love somebody but I don't know how
I wanna throw my body in the river and drown
-The Decemberists

But that isn't what this is, trying to distill it down to such a ridiculous claim is not really addressing the issues at all.

More like, if at any point in your life you have sexually assaulted someone, you should be fired or resign, yes! Let's not group all three of these accusations into the same category, they most certainly are not equal!

Now, as for the other two - if, when you were in college (where you should be old enough to know better), you partook in blatantly racist activities, and then later tried to deny you did so, you may well not be suited to your very public, public servant role. Being found to have been so insensitive to a group of citizens should make your suitability for your role questionable.

If you are smart, you'll come clean and say you recognize you did a very stupid thing in your youth and claim that at the time you didn't understand the full racial and historical implications of your actions, you may well be able to perform a level of damage control enough to keep your very public, public servant job.

But these aren't cases of just anyone doing anything ever in their lives that was the slightest bit questionable - this is an elected official who should represent his constituents, having chosen to publish and memorialize blatantly racist behavior in his college year book.

So again, this is not a case of "If at any point in your life, you have ever said or done something that a historically marginalized group would find offensive at some level". Blackface is not just something a historically marginalized group would find offensive at 'some level'. It is something that current marginalized groups have been historically, purposefully mocked with.

Yes, we can all say there are things we didn't realize were racist. Even white college kids can claim they really just didn't know the history of blackface. That very much speaks to their privilege of ignorance. But why do we expect so little of our politicians? Why assume everyone must have exactly this kind of thing hiding in their closet and therefore we shouldn't let social reaction ever affect anyone?

Public opinion should only count when it comes to... well, what exactly? What is the public allowed to be outraged about and what aren't they? When is the public allowed to hold someone accountable for past actions and when should the public be told to just shut up and accept their politician's flaws, no matter what they are? Why is the public being shamed for what the politician chose to do!?

Since everyone is racist, why should anyone be held accountable for their racist actions?? Is that the message?

Oh, and also sexual assault is just like racism, so we'll just bundle those things together and pretend they're the same thing.

_________________
Window seat for one,
Passage out of town
The old fashioned way:
Train ticket, out bound.
Midnight departure,
Red-eye double-track.
Star filled horizons,
Beacons in the black.
Last call for boarding,
Destination: nowhere.
Two carry-on bags
Ought to get me there.
Don’t know how far
‘Til my journey’s done;
Train ticket, out bound,
Window seat for one.

I agree that the allegation against Lt. Gov. Fairfax is by far the worst of the three.

That having been said, I certainly think that Democrats need to apply at least the same standards to themselves that they would to Republicans (regardless of whether the reverse is true). If they (we?) would call for the resignation of a Republican in the same position, they need to apply the standard to themselves.

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

Sure it is. You'd be hard pressed to find any offending remark or action of nearly any level made at any time by any public figure where this has not been the reaction from a huge swath of the left's recent outrage machine.

It reminds me a great deal of the time, many years ago it seems, when conservative groups had a louder voice in general media and were constantly morally outraged by all the sex, drugs, and violence in the media. The moral outrage!

Morals are good but puritanical zealotry, maybe not so much.

_________________
I wanna love somebody but I don't know how
I wanna throw my body in the river and drown
-The Decemberists

Outrage over sexual assault? How dare.



Media is a choice to consume. Politicians? Not really much choice once they're elected, they will affect your lives one way or another. Though I am happy to see someone acknowledge that it isn't just Liberals who are 'too sensitive and offended by everything'.

_________________
Window seat for one,
Passage out of town
The old fashioned way:
Train ticket, out bound.
Midnight departure,
Red-eye double-track.
Star filled horizons,
Beacons in the black.
Last call for boarding,
Destination: nowhere.
Two carry-on bags
Ought to get me there.
Don’t know how far
‘Til my journey’s done;
Train ticket, out bound,
Window seat for one.

Blackface is disgusting behavior that has thankfully been deemed socially unacceptable. It is not, however, a crime. If someone did it and has a track record of mended ways and a sincere apology on offer they shouldn't lose their job over it. If someone's trying to argue that their bad behavior should be accepted for reasons, they deserve whatever comes to them.
That said, I think Northam should rethink his career plans because his crisis management skills are clearly not up to snuff. The VA AG handled his embarrassment much better.

Sexual assault is disgusting behavior that is in the process of being deemed socially unacceptable. It is also a crime. Those accused should face investigation and justice. Fairfax has music to face. He ought to just shut his trap and do it.

_________________
When you can do nothing what can you do?

Except for calling for Northam's resignation without admitting that he had done the same thing.

Sent from my LG G6 using Tapatalk

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

I don't think public officials should necessarily resign over things they did in college; if they did it last weekend, sure. Generally speaking, judging actions of other eras through the lens of today's sensibilities isn't reasonable, imo.

_________________
Avatar photo by Richard Lykes, used with permission.

I do agree with this largely, but blackface wasn't acceptable in the 80's, either.

_________________
Window seat for one,
Passage out of town
The old fashioned way:
Train ticket, out bound.
Midnight departure,
Red-eye double-track.
Star filled horizons,
Beacons in the black.
Last call for boarding,
Destination: nowhere.
Two carry-on bags
Ought to get me there.
Don’t know how far
‘Til my journey’s done;
Train ticket, out bound,
Window seat for one.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-47162714





Two things: hard to argue this is a "Liberal/Democratic over-reaction" if Republicans are more than happy to jump on the bandwagon and say they aren't fit to govern. Also: Republicans did it, too, so I guess everything is now proverbially equal and all our politicians suck.

_________________
Window seat for one,
Passage out of town
The old fashioned way:
Train ticket, out bound.
Midnight departure,
Red-eye double-track.
Star filled horizons,
Beacons in the black.
Last call for boarding,
Destination: nowhere.
Two carry-on bags
Ought to get me there.
Don’t know how far
‘Til my journey’s done;
Train ticket, out bound,
Window seat for one.

A second woman has now accused Fairfax of sexual assault, this one even more serious, alleging that he raped her when they attended Duke University in 2000.

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

And a friend of hers has come forward to say she talked to her about the rape.

It's not looking good.

_________________
When you can do nothing what can you do?

I don't think there is any question that Fairfax needs to resign.

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

CBS This Morning



Do we have a face-palm emoticon? I can't find it over face-palming for real.

_________________

“It may help to understand human affairs to be clear that most of the great triumphs and tragedies of history are caused, not by people being fundamentally good or fundamentally bad, but by people being fundamentally people.”

- Terry Pratchett & Neil Gaiman, Good Omens

Perhaps that one should be cross-posted in the WTF thread.

_________________
'But very bright were the stars upon the margin of the world, when at times the clouds about the West were drawn aside.'

_________________
Window seat for one,
Passage out of town
The old fashioned way:
Train ticket, out bound.
Midnight departure,
Red-eye double-track.
Star filled horizons,
Beacons in the black.
Last call for boarding,
Destination: nowhere.
Two carry-on bags
Ought to get me there.
Don’t know how far
‘Til my journey’s done;
Train ticket, out bound,
Window seat for one.

I saw that Fairfax requested an investigation of the claims before people rush to judgment. That sounds reasonable to me.

_________________
Avatar photo by Richard Lykes, used with permission.

So the first blacks to arrive in Virginia were officially indentured servants. No idea if they actually got freed at the end of their indenture. Later the system changed to straight up slavery. I'm not sure why...but it might be important to find out why the downgrade happened. Especially since it didn't also happen to poor whites who took indentures to come to the colonies, or were sent as convicts.

Source
From the section headed "From Servitude to Slavery":

_________________
When you can do nothing what can you do?

WaPo opinion piece.

Was everyone terrible 30 years ago?

_________________

“It may help to understand human affairs to be clear that most of the great triumphs and tragedies of history are caused, not by people being fundamentally good or fundamentally bad, but by people being fundamentally people.”

- Terry Pratchett & Neil Gaiman, Good Omens